When it comes to updating your look with some fresh color, the choices can be overwhelming. Two of the most popular hair coloring techniques are balayage and highlights. Understanding the nuances between these styles is key to making a decision that aligns with your hair type and beauty goals.
Choosing between balayage vs. highlights requires an understanding of how they differ and how to pick the right option. Whether you’re seeking a dramatic change or a subtle enhancement, this guide will help you navigate the world of hair coloring so that you can achieve your desired outcome. Let’s delve into the specifics of each technique and find out which might be the right pick for your locks.

Table of Contents
Understanding balayage and highlights
Balayage is a French hair coloring technique that’s been around since the 1970s. It’s a freehand technique where color is applied by hand rather than using traditional foiling or cap highlighting methods. This approach creates a more natural, sun-kissed look with softer, less noticeable regrowth lines.
Highlights, on the other hand, involve sectioning off hair and applying color or lightener using foils. This method allows for more precise application, resulting in a more uniform finish. Highlights can vary in size from fine to chunky, depending on the desired effect.

The main difference between the two comes down to the application process and the overall finish. While balayage offers a more natural, lived-in look, highlights provide a more defined and structured color pattern.

Choosing based on hair type
When considering balayage vs. highlights, your hair type plays a significant role in deciding which technique will work best. Balayage works on all hair lengths except very short cropped hair. It’s especially stunning on wavy or curly hair as the color enhances the natural hair texture.
Highlights can also be applied to any hair length and type, but the technique is particularly well-suited for those with straight hair who desire a uniform look. If you have fine hair and are looking to add dimension, highlights can create the illusion of volume and depth.

Balayage vs highlights on dark hair
Dark-haired beauties might wonder which technique will better suit their rich hues. Balayage on dark hair produces a stunning, gradual lightening effect that can appear more natural. It’s an excellent choice if you’re seeking a subtle transition from dark to lighter shades.
Highlights on dark hair can offer a stronger contrast and are generally more noticeable. For those wanting to make a bold statement or add significant lightness, traditional highlights might be the go-to option. Consider how much of a contrast you’re aiming for before making your decision.
Maintenance and upkeep
One of the key advantages of balayage is its low-maintenance nature. The technique allows for a more graceful grow-out period, meaning you can go longer between salon visits. This is perfect for individuals with busy lifestyles or those who prefer a more natural progression of color.

Highlights, while beautiful, typically require more frequent touch-ups to maintain the contrast and prevent visible regrowth. If you don’t mind the commitment to regular salon visits, highlights can be a fantastic way to keep your hair looking vibrant.
Cost and time investment
- Balayage can be more costly upfront because it’s a specialized technique that requires skill and expertise.
- However, given its lower maintenance, the long-term cost may balance out as you’ll need fewer salon visits.
- Highlights may be less expensive per session but consider the cost of more frequent touch-ups.
- Time investment is also a factor; balayage sessions can be lengthy, whereas highlights might be quicker but require more visits.
Expert tips for best results
For the best results, always consult with a professional colorist who can provide tailored advice for your hair type and color aspirations. They can help you weigh the pros and cons of balayage vs. highlights and decide which technique will achieve your desired outcome.

Whether you choose balayage or highlights, proper aftercare is essential. Invest in color-protecting hair care products and avoid excessive heat styling to maintain the health and longevity of your color.

Remember, you don’t have to choose just one technique. Many people opt for a combination of balayage and highlights to create a customized, dimensional look. Discuss hybrid options with your stylist for a unique color blend.
Balayage vs. Highlights: Understanding your hair goals
When deciding on balayage vs. highlights, it’s crucial to have a clear understanding of your hair goals. Are you looking for a dramatic transformation or a subtle enhancement? Do you prefer a low-maintenance style or are you willing to invest time and money in upkeep?

Understanding the impact each technique has on your appearance and lifestyle will guide you towards the right choice. Discuss your objectives with your stylist to ensure your expectations align with the possibilities of each coloring method.
Related questions about hair coloring choices
How to decide between balayage and highlights?
To make the right decision between balayage and highlights, consider your lifestyle, maintenance preferences, and the look you want. Balayage is ideal for a more natural, low-maintenance style, while highlights are best for a structured, high-contrast look.
Also, think about how often you’re willing to visit the salon for touch-ups. If less frequent visits are a priority, balayage might be your best bet.

What are the disadvantages of balayage?
The disadvantages of balayage include potentially higher initial costs and longer appointment times. It may not provide the level of brightness some clients expect, especially after just one session.
While it’s a lower maintenance option, achieving the desired effect can sometimes require multiple sessions, which is something to consider when choosing this technique.

What is more expensive, balayage or highlights?
Generally, balayage is more expensive than highlights due to the skill level required and the custom nature of the technique. However, the reduced frequency of salon visits for upkeep can offset the initial cost over time.

Highlights might seem more affordable per session, but the cumulative cost of more frequent maintenance could add up.
Does balayage look more natural than highlights?
Yes, balayage tends to look more natural than highlights because of the hand-painted technique used to apply the color. It creates a softer, more diffused color transition that mimics the way hair naturally lightens in the sun.

Highlights can also appear natural, but they are typically more uniform and noticeable, which might not be as subtle as the effect created by balayage.
For those interested in learning more about these techniques visually, YouTube videos are a great resource. Let’s take a look at a video detailing the balayage process.

In conclusion, whether you opt for the sweeping allure of balayage or the striking precision of highlights, you’ll be stepping into the salon with confidence, armed with the knowledge to pick the option that’ll make your hair goals a reality.
